Tianna Brodeur awarded $5.2 million for VBAC birth

Tianna Brodeur awarded $5.2 million for VBAC birth

A B.C Judge has ruled in favor of Tianna Brodeur awarding her $5.2 million since her cerebral palsy has been attributed to malpractice from nurses and doctor during her birth. The 16-year-old teenager, according to the B.C. Supreme Court judgment, suffered brain damage due to the asphyxia when the mother’s previous Cesarean section ruptured during delivery.

The ruling provides details of what is known as vaginal birth after Cesarean section or VBAC.  Justice Neena Sharma wrote in her 82-page decision, “Amanda Brodeur gave birth to a baby girl on September 21, 1999. Instead of an occasion filled with joy and happiness, it was a traumatic event which left her daughter with life-long cognitive and physical disabilities."

According to the document, the doctor and nurses failed to recognize the gravity of the situation and did not act accordingly. 

Usually, when a woman has had C-section for delivery, it is established that her next deliveries will be the same since doctors are not willing to take risks.  However, more doctors are choosing the option of VBAC due to the complications that may arise from a C-section. Sharma writes that "This was preferred in order to reduce the risks associated with caesarean section deliveries…”

According to Amanda Brodeur’s family, she was not given enough details of the risks associated with a VBAC birth. Of the details of Amanda’s delivery, it is stated that at 18:30, the mother was nauseated and vomiting. At 21:54 the baby´s heart rate had dropped.  This is where the actions of Dr. Dayna Freedman were studied.

According to Sharma, Freedman failed on two occasions: "by failing to immediately recognize the report of unusual pain as a possible sign of uterine rupture, and by not immediately calling" a senior doctor.”

Teenager Tianna Brodeur is not completely disabled but it she will never be able to lead an independent life.  Her parents recognize that they will care for her until they die at which time she would move on to live with her sister.  The cost of future care was estimated by the judge to be $3.2 million with a total amount of damages adding up to $5.2 million.

The hospital has not issued an official report about the decision. 

What's Hottest

Get the latest & hottest

Allyson Felix Overcomes Injury in Olympics Trials

Allyson Felix Overcomes Injury in Olympics Trials

Allyson Felix, one of the most notable American athletes, has proven beyond doubt that she is committed and determined to become the first US woman to win gold in both 400 and 200-meter races. Since her debut into the Olympics limelight, she has won six medals; one is a gold medal that she won in…

  • Track & Field athletes - Veronica Campbell-Brown, Shelly-Ann Fraser-Pryce

    Veronica Campbell-Brown Veronica Campbell-Brown is the youngest Jamaican female to win an Olympic medal. At the 2012 Olympic Games, she was a six-time Olympic medalist. Veronica Campbell-Brown was born May 15, 1982. A seven-time Olympic champion, she is the second lady in history to win two…
  • Manon Rhéaume breaks new ground for women

    Manon Rhéaume is a Canadian ice hockey goaltender and also an Olympic silver medalist. She accomplished a variety of historical firsts during her career. Manon Rhéaume was the first woman to play on an American hockey team when she, in 1992, she signed as a goalie with the National…
  • What is the Women's Sports Foundation?

    Also known as WSF, the Women's Sport Foundation is essentially a non-profit foundation dedicated to encourage and support the role of women in sports. It was founded in 1974 by Billie Jean King, one of the greatest tennis players of all time, and her husband Larry King. Billie won the award for…
  • Who is the most famous female tennis player?

    The game has given us tremendous female players during the last years. There are several nominees, including Venus Williams, Maria Sharapova, Serena Williams, Chris Evert, and Monica Seles. Considering prizes, awards, trophies and income, we have to narrow it down to Serena Williams and Maria…
  • Canadian Women's Basketball Team Qualifies for 2016 Olympics

    The Canadians beat Cuba 82-66 this Sunday, at the FIBA Americas women’s basketball finals. As Kia Nurse advanced the team with 20 points, they won the gold medal for the game and it’s official – they have now qualified for the next year’s Olympic Games! Nurse was honored as…
Five new sports added to Tokyo’s Olympic Games 2020

Five new sports added to Tokyo’s Olympic Games 2020

The 2016 Olympic Games conclude on 21st of August. The games were quite a spectacle, and now the next Games has been awarded to Tokyo, Japan in the year 2020. Tokyo last hosted the games in 1998; this will be their second chance at hosting the global event. A host of new games will appear on the…

  • NHL Coming to Vegas

    On June 22nd, the NHL’s board of governors unanimously approved expanding the franchise to Las Vegas making the currently unnamed team the 31st team in the league. The franchise will play in the Pacific Division and the current NHL playoff structure will not change. The next move for the team…
  • Two Ethiopians win Boston Marathon

    Running a marathon is a big life accomplishment for many, and one of the most prestigious in America is the Boston Marathon. Almost all runners train to either finish, or beat a personal best. It’s easy to forget that it is indeed a race, and there will be a winner who crosses the finish line…
  • Three of the highest paid NHL players

    When it comes to contracts for major sports players, we are used to pretty large amounts of money and sweet endorsements that thicken up the bank account even more. It is known that the NFL is the league that pays its players well, with Jay Cutler cutting a deal of $124 million with the Chicago…
  • Ovechkin hits 500

    If you are a fan of the NHL, you have been following Alexander Ovechkin from the beginning of his career. The Russian player recently reached 500 goals, making him the first Russian NHL player to reach this number. The 30 year old player marked his 500th goal in a match against the Ottawa Senators a…
  • Djokovic wins the US Open title in September

    It is all happiness for Djokovic as he became the new US Open Champion beating Roger Federer in 4 exciting sets in front of 23,000 fans at the Arthur Ashe Stadium. This would be the Serbian’s 10th grand slam. With scores of 6-4, 5-7, 6-4, 6-4, Djokovic won the championship on Sunday, September…

The Spot Light

Get what's the most famous today

Canada’s Rugby Sevens team

Canada’s Rugby Sevens team

The Canada national Rugby Sevens team and the Canada women's national Sevens Rugby Union team are Canada´s representatives of Rugby Sevens for Canada in several international major tournaments. These tournaments include: the Sevens World Series, Pan American Games, the Commonwealth Games,…

Lionel Messi in Trouble Over Tax Evasion

Lionel Messi in Trouble Over Tax Evasion

Lionel Messi is an Argentine sports superstar and is regarded as the best football player of all time. But this does not excuse Messi from having to pay for violating the law. Lionel and his father have to stand trial as ruled by the court in Spain. The judge handling the case did not grant the…

NEWS FLASH

WHAT'S IN THE GOSSIPS TODAY